When I was buying my new-to-me car, the salesperson asked me a question that I don’t think anyone has ever asked me before. He said, “Are you the type of person who likes to read a lot of opinions about something before you make a decision? If you are, I can point you to some websites.” I didn’t even have to think about the answer to that question. “No,” I said, “I don’t find reading opinions very useful.”
I had never thought about that being a “type of person” before, but suddenly, the whole world made sense to me! (Well, OK, maybe not the whole world, but the internet at the very least.) One of my least favorite things about the internet is that everyone seems to voice an opinion on everything, regardless of their level of knowledge or experience. There are discussion boards and comment features on everything. I’m all for healthy debate, collegial discussions, and thoughtful presentation of ideas. But responding to a newspaper article by saying, “Well that guy is just an idiot!” is not helpful to anyone. Is it? And chances are good that if I had taken the car salesperson up on his offer, he would have pointed me to a website where people had good things and bad things to say about whatever car I was looking at. And chances are extremely good that none of them would have really addressed the concerns that I had about the car I was thinking of buying anyway (which was “does the claustrophobic feeling of this car ever go away?!” <– this is why I bought used and not new, by the way, as the new cars are shorter than older ones).
But, even outside of purchases, I am the “type of person” who might seek counsel from a select few, very knowledgable people on some issue to add to my point of view, but then I do what I know to be best at that time. I’ve made decisions to begin and end graduate programs without seeking much advice on the matter. I decided on which apartment to move into on my own. If I pursue purchase of a home (condo) in a few years, I’ll like start looking and proceed through with purchase without much, if any, involvement of other people. My decisions are not impulsive or ill-informed, but they are not globally informed either. I rarely need random feedback, and I don’t go seek it from strangers, as a general rule. And unless someone I know knows a great deal about something (like my brother knows a lot about cars), then I don’t ask them either. I just don’t.
So, no, I am not the type of person who will read a lot, or even any, opinions online in order to make decisions. Are you?